020 7183 8950 | info@brettwilson.co.uk

Half time ruling/no case to answer submission

If the defence in criminal proceedings are of the view that the prosecution have failed to raise a case to answer, they may make a submission that there is "no case to answer". This will take place at the halfway point in a trial (i.e. between the prosecution case and defence case).
In the Crown Court, a submission that there is no case to answer will be heard by a judge in the absence of the jury. Counsel for the defence will make his/her submissions first of all and then the counsel for the prosecution will have a chance to respond. The submissions should address whether evidence was adduced in relation to each required element of the offence and whether the evidence was reliable enough for a jury to convict on.
The test for the judge to consider is whether, taking the prosecution's case at its highest, a properly directed jury could not properly convict on it. If the judge finds that this is the case then he/she should direct the jury to acquit the defendant. If the judge finds finds that there is a case to answer then the trial will continue and the jury will hear the defence case before then making a determination on the evidence themselves.
A half-time ruling in favour of the defendant is a "terminating ruling" that can be appealed by the prosecution to the Court of Appeal.
A submission of "no case to answer" may also be made halfway through a magistrates' court trial where:-
1) The prosecution have failed to put forward evidence to prove an essential element of the alleged offence; or
2) The evidence adduced has been so unreliable or discredited that no reasonable tribunal could safely convict on it.
If such an application is successful the case will be dismissed.

Simply send us an emailcomplete our online enquiry form or call us on 020 7183 8950.